Warrington Borough Council has announced plans to develop a comprehensive policy aimed at controlling the growth of Houses in Multiple Occupation (HMOs) across the borough. The proposal, currently under review, is expected to lead to the introduction of new planning measures, likely through expanded Article 4 Directions in additional areas beyond the existing three zones.

This development has sparked significant discussion among property investors, landlords, and housing professionals across Warrington and the wider North West. As someone with extensive experience managing HMOs in the region, I wanted to break down what this means for both current and prospective investors.

Understanding Article 4 Directions

Under normal circumstances, landlords can convert a single-family dwelling into a small HMO (up to six occupants) under permitted development rights. However, an Article 4 Direction removes these rights, meaning landlords must apply for full planning permission to make such conversions.

Warrington already has three small Article 4 areas that remove permitted development rights:
- Works (Campbells), Liverpool Road
- Cherry Lane, Lymm 
- Old Smithy, Gig Lane, Thelwall

The new policy suggests this approach may be expanded borough-wide or to additional areas, giving the council greater control over HMO developments and their impact on local communities and infrastructure.

The Market Reality: A Tale of Two Standards

The discussion around this policy has highlighted a crucial divide in the HMO market. As one local investor recently shared:

"I'm fully onboard with this. Should hopefully wean out the HMOs that are badly managed, ours in the area are properly and proactively managed (hence why we're up for 3 awards on Friday at the HMO awards) and I'm sick and tired of being tarred with the same brush as the badly managed ones."

This sentiment reflects what many professional landlords experience – being unfairly associated with poor-quality operators who damage the sector's reputation.

Impact on Existing HMO Owners

For those already operating legally compliant and well-managed HMOs, this policy could prove beneficial:

Potential Benefits:
- Increased property values: As one investor noted, "This might push up the value of existing HMOs" due to restricted future supply
- Reduced competition: Fewer new HMO conversions mean less competition for quality tenants
- Market differentiation: Professional operators can distinguish themselves from substandard providers
- Rental stability: Limited supply could support stronger rental yields

Key Considerations:
- Ensure all existing properties meet current licensing and management standards
- Stay compliant with evolving regulations to maintain competitive advantage
- Consider the enhanced reputation benefits of operating quality HMOs

Challenges for New Investors

For those looking to enter the HMO market in Warrington or expand existing portfolios, the proposed changes introduce additional hurdles:

Planning Uncertainty: Applications bring cost, time delays, and no guarantee of approval
Increased Barriers: Higher entry costs may limit opportunities for smaller investors
Strategic Limitations: Borough-wide restrictions could significantly impact conversion-based strategies

As one investor observed: "This might push up the value of existing HMOs but does make it harder for those looking to add to their portfolio."

The Broader Context

This move reflects a nationwide trend, with councils like Manchester, Derby, and Middlesbrough implementing similar Article 4 directions. The objectives typically include:

- Managing HMO concentration in specific areas
- Maintaining neighbourhood character and community balance
- Ensuring developments meet appropriate standards
- Giving councils greater planning control

Strategic Recommendations for Investors

Based on my experience in the North West property market and as an NRLA member, here's what I recommend:

For Current HMO Owners:
1. Audit your standards: Ensure properties exceed minimum requirements
2. Document compliance: Maintain detailed records of all safety and licensing requirements
3. Invest in quality: Use this as an opportunity to differentiate through superior management

For Prospective Investors:
1. Monitor developments: Stay updated on Warrington Council's consultation timeline
2. Consider timing: Evaluate whether to accelerate planned conversions before restrictions take effect
3. Diversify locations: Explore opportunities in areas with fewer restrictions
4. Focus on planning-led purchases: Consider properties with existing planning permissions

For All Investors:
1. Engage locally: Join property networks and forums to share insights
2. Professional development: Stay informed about regulatory changes and best practices
3. Quality over quantity: Focus on fewer, higher-standard properties rather than volume

Looking Ahead

While regulatory changes can create uncertainty, they also present opportunities for professional investors who adapt strategically. Well-managed HMOs that provide quality accommodation will likely benefit from reduced competition and potentially higher values.

The key question remains whether the council will implement a borough-wide Article 4 Direction or limit it to specific neighbourhoods. Either way, success in this evolving landscape will depend on adaptability, compliance, and maintaining the highest standards.

Final Thoughts

Warrington's move to control HMO growth represents a significant shift in the local property investment landscape. While it may pose new challenges, it also creates opportunities for professional landlords to differentiate themselves and for current HMO owners to benefit from increased scarcity.

As always, success in property investing comes down to staying informed, being proactive, and maintaining the highest standards. Those who embrace these principles will continue to thrive, regardless of regulatory changes.

Want to stay ahead of market developments like this? Subscribe to our newsletter for regular insights, or book a free 15-minute consultation to discuss how these changes might affect your property investment strategy.